If you have never walked into a Jersey Mike’s, here is the first thing you notice — someone is slicing real meat on a deli slicer, right in front of you. No pre-packed proteins. No mystery fillings. Just fresh-cut deli meat on house-baked bread, made to order since 1956.

With so many options on the menu, first-timers often freeze up at the counter. That is why we put together this list — the 7 best Jersey Mike’s subs you should try, ranked by fan popularity, flavour, and overall value.

Want to see the full lineup before you go? Check our complete Jersey Mike’s Menu Guide for every sub, price, and calorie count.

1. #13 Original Italian – The Fan Favourite

If there is one sub that defines Jersey Mike’s, it is the #13 Original Italian. Six proteins layered together — pepperoni, ham, prosciuttini, cappacuolo, salami, and provolone — all sliced fresh and finished Mike’s Way.

Mike’s Way means onions, shredded lettuce, tomatoes, red wine vinegar, olive oil blend, and oregano added at the end. It completely transforms the sandwich. The vinegar cuts through the richness of the meat. The oregano adds a punch of flavour that is hard to describe until you have tasted it.

This is the sub that converts people. Order it on a Regular or Giant. Start here if you are new to Jersey Mike’s.

2. #56 Big Kahuna Cheese Steak – The Hot Sub King

From the hot subs side, the Big Kahuna Cheese Steak is the clear winner. Grilled steak, onions, peppers, mushrooms, jalapeños, and extra white American cheese — all cooked together on a flat-top grill until the bread toasts from direct contact.

It comes in at around 800 calories for a Regular. Want to see exactly how it compares to other hot options? Visit our Hot Subs Menu for the full breakdown.

3. #8 Club Sub – The Classic That Never Gets Old

Turkey, ham, and provolone on fresh-baked bread. Simple, clean, and consistently good. The Club Sub is the order for people who want something familiar but still want quality above what any other chain offers.

Ask for it Mike’s Way and it immediately becomes a different sandwich. This is also a great choice for kids who are not ready for something as bold as the Italian. Speaking of which — check our dedicated guide on the Jersey Mike’s Kids Menu.

4. #7 Turkey and Provolone – Best for Light Eaters

Fresh-sliced turkey with provolone is one of the cleanest options on the menu. Order it as a Mini with Mike’s Way and you are looking at a meal well under 400 calories that still feels satisfying.

This sub is the go-to recommendation for anyone watching calories or looking for a lighter lunch. For full nutrition details on every sub, visit our Jersey Mike’s Nutrition Guide.

5. #17 Mike’s Famous Philly – A Grilled Classic

Grilled steak, onions, peppers, and white American cheese. The Philly is one of the most ordered hot subs and for good reason — the bread picks up heat from the grill and the cheese melts directly into the steak.

A pro tip from regulars: ask for Mike’s Way on your Philly. The red wine vinegar against the grilled steak is an underrated combination that long-time fans swear by.

6. #5 The Super Sub – When You Are Really Hungry

Provolone, ham, and prosciuttini piled high. The Super Sub lives up to its name. Order it as a Giant and you have a serious meal. This is the sub that office workers order when they know they will not have time for another break.

Feeding a group? The Super Sub also works great as part of a catering order. See our Jersey Mike’s Catering Menu for group ordering options.

7. Sub in a Tub – The Secret Menu Star

Technically not on the printed menu, but every Jersey Mike’s employee knows this order. Any sub, built without the bread, served in a bowl with full Mike’s Way dressing. Same price. Zero bread. All the flavor.

This is the number one order for keto dieters, low-carb eaters, and anyone avoiding gluten. The #13 Original Italian as a Sub in a Tub is particularly popular because the oil and vinegar dressing stands on its own without the bread absorbing it.

Want to explore more hidden ordering tricks? Read our full Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu Guide.

Tips Before You Order

• Always ask for Mike’s Way on cold subs — it is free and it improves every sandwich
• Mini size is ideal for kids and light eaters
• Giant size feeds two people comfortably
• Sub in a Tub works on any sub — just ask at the counter
• Sign up for MyMike’s app to earn Shore Points and get a free sub on your birthday

Final Word

Jersey Mike’s earns its reputation through one simple commitment — fresh-sliced meat, fresh-baked bread, made right in front of you. Whether you go with the iconic #13 Italian, a grilled Philly, or a keto-friendly Sub in a Tub, you are getting a better quality sandwich than almost anything else in the fast casual space.

Before your next visit, check the full Jersey Mike’s Menu Prices so you know exactly what to expect at the counter.