Jersey Mike’s Cold Subs Menu – Full Sub List, Numbers & Ordering Guide (2026)
Cold subs are the foundation of Jersey Mike’s. Every protein is sliced fresh on a deli slicer the moment you order – not pre-packaged, not sitting in a tray. That’s a Northeast deli tradition dating back to 1956 that Jersey Mike’s still follows at every single location.
This page covers every cold sub by number, prices, best builds, and the Mike’s Way finishing technique that separates a great Jersey Mike’s order from an average one.
Jersey Mike’s Cold Subs – Full Menu by Number:
“Also check our Hot Subs Menu for grilled options”
#8 Club Sub
Turkey, ham, provolone,
US$8.50 | Cal:～850
Sub numbers are consistent across all US locations. The Canada menu may vary slightly.
What Is Mike’s Way?
Mike’s Way is the Jersey Mike’s finishing technique applied to cold subs. It’s not a topping – it’s a process:
- Shredded lettuce
- Sliced onions
- Sliced tomatoes
- Red wine vinegar drizzle
- Olive oil blend drizzle
- Dried oregano and spices
All of it applied at the end, after your main toppings. Free on every cold sub. Mike’s Way is what turns a good sub into a Jersey Mike’s sub — the acid from the vinegar cuts through the richness of the meat and cheese. Ask for it every single time.
Cold Subs – Prices 2025:
| Sub | Mini | Regular | Giant |
| BLT (#1) | $6 – $7 | $9 – $10 | $14 – $16 |
| Turkey & Provolone (#7) | $6 – $8 | $9 – $11 | $14 – $17 |
| Club Supreme (#9) | $7 – $8 | $10 – $12 | $15 – $18 |
| Original Italian (#13) | $7 – $9 | $10 – $12 | $15 – $18 |
| California Club (#56) | $7 – $9 | $10 – $13 | $15 – $19 |
Cold Subs Calories – Quick Reference:
| Sub (Regular, Mike’s Way) | Approx. Calories |
| BLT (#1) | 450 – 500 |
| Turkey & Provolone (#7) | 500 – 550 |
| Club Sub (#8) | 580 – 640 |
| Club Supreme (#9) | 620 – 680 |
| Tuna Fish (#10) | 680 – 730 |
| Veggie (#11) | 380 – 430 |
| Original Italian (#13) | 750 – 800 |
| California Club (#56) | 620 – 700 |
Cold Subs Calories – Quick Reference:
Best overall: #13 Original Italian
Six proteins, fresh-sliced, Mike’s Way. The most ordered sub on the menu by a significant margin. Start here if you’ve never been.
Best for low calories: #11 Veggie or #7 Turkey & Provolone
Veggie with Mike’s Way comes in under 430 calories. Turkey & Provolone is the lowest-calorie meat sub on the menu.
Best for protein: #9 Club Supreme, double meat
Turkey, roast beef, provolone – doubled. North of 65g protein on a Giant. The gym crowd’s go-to order.
Best for flavor complexity: #2 Jersey Shore’s Favourite
Ham and cappacuolo together – the spiced pork adds heat and depth that plain ham doesn’t have. Underrated sub.
Best for newcomers: #13 Original Italian or #9 Club Supreme
Both represent what Jersey Mike’s does best. Both are Mike’s Way naturals. Both have regulars who’ve ordered nothing else for years.
Cold Sub Ordering Hacks:
- Sub in a Tub – any cold sub without bread, same price. Best low-carb option on the menu.
- Extra cappacuolo on the #13 – Reddit’s most recommended modification. Shifts the heat profile significantly.
- Ask for ‘drowned’ – extra oil and vinegar beyond standard Mike’s Way. Old-school regular move.
- Double meat on any sub – available at upcharge. Transforms a Regular into a serious one.
- Mike’s Way with extra oregano – ask for it specifically. Most staff will oblige.